A Gold CAC 1805 Brings "All The Money" in the Stack's Bowers 11/2026 Auction

As a continuation of the last few blogs that I’ve written, the focus of this is a continuation of the theme of coins that have flown somewhat under the radar but which—in my opinion—are important. The coin in question is an EF40 1805 half eagle in PCGS that has been awarded a gold CAC sticker. It just sold at the November 2026 Stacks Bowers auction as Lot 2135 where it brought a very strong $31,720

Half Eagle. 1805 $5 gold coin. PCGS EF40 CAC Gold Sticker.

1805 $5.00 PCGS EF40, CAC Gold Sticker, image courtesy of stack’s bowers

Gold CAC stickers on early gold issues are rare and highly sought after by collectors. According to the most recent CAC population figures, there are a total of just 21 Draped Bust half eagles that have been awarded a gold sticker as of mid-November 2026. For the 1805, there have been three: this coin, and two in AU55.

Clearly, this coin was very conservatively graded as an EF40; even by the grading standards of when this coin was slabbed (it was in a Generation 3.0 slab which meant that it was graded and encapsulated between 1990 and early 1993). I graded it AU55.

This sale was significant for a couple of reasons.

$31,720 is a ton of money for a circulated 1805 half eagle. To put it in perspective, the coin that sold immediately before this piece (offered as Lot 2134) was an 1800 graded AU58+ by PCGS and with a green CAC sticker. It sold for $23,180, which I regard as a strong price. Putting the coins side-by-side—as I did when I lot viewed—I liked the 1800 a bit more.

As recently as 2025, the 1805 $5 would have likely been cracked out of its holder and the submitter would likely have been pleased to have the coin in a new AU55 or an AU58 holder. (And it is highly likely that the newly-holdered coin would have stickered at CAC.)

But the market has dictated that cracking out any gold CAC coin is a mistake, as this 1805 half eagle shows.

You could likely have sold the exact same coin in a 55 or a 58 holder for around $20,000. Or you could sell a comparable coin in a 40 holder for $10,000 more.

By awarding gold stickers to lovely original coins, CAC has accidentally on purpose helped to preserve the relatively few old holder pre-1834 gold coins that still exist. Of course, this will never bring back the thousands of early coins graded ca. 1990, nor will it restore the hundreds of pre-1834 gold coins that were ruined in the hope of an upgrade. At least it saved the 1805 half eagle.

I’ve commented on this before but we have now reached the point in the Capped Bust half eagle market where a nice PCGS/CAC AU58 coin is worth 20++% more than a commercial quality non-CAC MS62. I can’t think of many other series in which this is the case but it is fast becoming the reality of today’s coin market.