Why No Motto Philadelphia Half Eagles May be the Best Value in Today's Dated Gold Market

The rare date gold market is now fairly mature and many areas which were formerly overlooked and undervalued (like San Francisco half eagles and eagles, New Orleans half eagles and eagles and Type One Liberty Head double eagles) are now very popular with collectors. There are still coins which are “sleepers” but you just have to look harder these days to find them.

I have written these words before but I still feel that the No Motto Philadelphia half eagle date run, issued from 1840 through 1865, contains a number of under-appreciated issues. These issues clearly don’t include the 1862-1865 which are now in strong demand due to their Civil War issuance, but which do include nearly all the dates made between 1840 and 1861.

   1849 $5.00 PCGS AU55 CAC

1849 $5.00 PCGS AU55 CAC

I was recently able to pick a few dozen nice About Uncirculated common and slightly better date No Motto Philadelphia half eagles from a remarkable group of pieces which has been in Europe until recently. These coins, all of which are freshly graded by PCGS and in some cases approved by CAC, are amazingly fresh and have a century worth of dirt caked over undipped, vibrant surfaces. I will soon be offering these to my DWN Preferred Clients via a series of emails.

(Not a member? There's a big sign up button at the bottom of the page!)

Here are five reasons why I feel these coins are poised for an upswing in collector demand:

1.  They Come Nice

Unlike branch mint half eagles which are typically found bright from having been processed, some of these Philadelphia No Motto half eagles because of a variety of factors (mainly due to their relatively low value) come with lovely, natural color. Many of the coins graded AU53 or even AU55 are undergraded but it doesn’t pay to try these multiple times at PCGS due to lack of upside. This is clearly not the case for, say, Charlotte half eagles where an upgrade from 53 to 55 can mean a few thousand dollars.

2. They Are Affordable, Even In Relatively High Grades

I can think of more than a dozen No Motto P mint half eagles which are $1,000 or less in nice AU, and many of these are less than $2,000 in MS61. If you don’t have the $5,000-10,000+ per coin budget it takes to be a player in the Southern branch mint half eagle market, you can buy really nice coins in the Philadelphia half eagle market at a price point which will still be in your comfort zone.

3. You Can Assemble Impressive Date Runs

Looking at the 1840-1857 Philadelphia half eagles, one thing I immediately see is the possibility of assembling long date runs. Here is my quick analysis of these coins:

LEVEL ONE: RARE

  • 1842 Small Letters
  • 1842 Large Letters

Both are rare coins with well under 100 known per issue. Despite this fact, it is possible to purchase a very decent example of one or both in the $2,500-3,500+ price range.

LEVEL TWO: SCARCE

  • 1840 Wide Mill
  • 1841
  • 1850
  • 1859
  • 1860

All five of these dates are scarce, especially in higher grades. That said, it is possible to acquire a decent example of each in the $1,500-2,500 range. The 1840 Wide Mill is an optional issue but as it is easy to see with the naked eye, I generally include it as a “regular issue.”

LEVEL THREE: MODERATELY SCARCE

  • 1846 Large Date
  • 1849
  • 1858

These three dates are somewhat challenging but with patience, the collector should be able to procure nice examples in the $1,000-1,500 range.

LEVEL FOUR: COMMON

  • 1840 Narrow Mill
  • 1843
  • 1844
  • 1845
  • 1846 Small Date
  • 1847
  • 1848
  • 1851
  • 1852
  • 1853
  • 1854
  • 1855
  • 1856
  • 1857
  • 1861

No less than 15 dates in this series are what I would call “common.” It is possible to acquire a nice, crusty AU example of any of these dates in the $750-1,250 range.

4. Abundant Varieties= Uncharted Territory

If you are the sort of collector who likes to chart undiscovered numismatic waters, then Philadelphia No Motto half eagles are for you. Because of their relatively high mintage figures, it is likely that a host of interesting varieties exist for these coins. Some, like the 1847 with an errant 1 placed in Liberty’s neck, the 1849 double date, or the 1854 with a noticeably doubled earlobe are already semi-well known. But others are waiting to be discovered or re-discovered. And there is the possibility of cherrypicking new varieties with no price premium.

Note: I would suggest buying a set of the three Bass catalogs (issued by Bowers and Merena in 1999 and 2000) devoted to selling Liberty Head gold coins. Bass was a fervent collector of half eagle varieties and his holdings serve as a roadmap to the nascent variety collector.

5. Small Premiums

According to the website coinflation.com, the melt price for a Liberty Head half eagle (based on current gold spot of $1,322/oz.) is $319.72. When you consider that you can purchase a common date No Motto Philadelphia half eagle in nice AU for less than $800, that seems like awfully good value. Put another way, you are paying just over 2x melt for a numismatically desirable coin.

There are interesting numismatic comparisons to make as well. Let’s take the 1849-P in AU55 as an example (a coin which I have just happen to have in stock as part of this offer...). The current PCGS population is 9 in this grade with 20 finer. You can buy one for under $1,500. Let’s compare it to its southern counterpart, the 1849-C. In AU55 PCGS has graded 26 with 22 finer. You’ll spend around $4,000 for a decent PCGS example. Do the math: doesn’t the 1849-P seems pretty undervalued in comparison to the 1849-C?

Look for a series of offers featuring Philadelphia No Motto half eagles beginning around the 16th of September. If you are a DWN Preferred Client, you will receive these. Not a Preferred Client? Click the big button below.