One of the most significant auction sales held during the 1990’s was the John Jay Pittman Collection. Conducted over the course of three years and held in three different sessions in Baltimore, the sales were conducted by David Akers and featured an amazing array of United States and foreign gold, silver and copper issues. The first Pittman sale was held in October 1997. It’s hard for me to believe that the twelve year anniversary of this auction just passed as it really seems like it was just yesterday that I flew to Baltimore to examine the coins, bid on the lots and compete against most of the major collectors and dealers in the United States. It was an intense but fun four or five days in Charm City.
Dave Akers astutely concluded that it would be more interesting (and profitable) to split up the Pittman United States issues into two segments and the gold denominations that were featured in the first sale included dollars, half eagles and double eagles. Not including a group of Proof Sets that had gold coins, there were over 500 lots of gold, most of which hadn’t been offered since the 1940’s or the early 1950’s.
I remember viewing the lots and being extremely impressed with the quality. I hadn’t really known much about the Pittman collection except that I had seen his displays of early Proof coins at various coins shows in the 1970’s and 1980’s. I was expecting some very impressive Proof gold (and wasn’t disappointed). It was the business strike issues, though, that intrigued me most and which offered some of the biggest surprises in the days that lay ahead.
The first gold dollar that really caught my eye was lot 863, a superb gem 1854-S that even the notoriously conservative Dave Akers called “Gem Uncirculated” in the catalog. I graded the coin MS66 to MS67 and was amazed by the quality. It sold for $33,000 to a tall dealer from Oklahoma.
The most impressive Proof Gold Dollar was a nice example of the very rare 1854 Type Two which, according to Akers, was one of just four known and one of just two not impounded in museum collections. It brought $176,000 and I graded it a solid PR64. This was one of the coins that Pittman became famous for employing his aggressive bidding technique at the Melish sale in 1956. Legend has it that for this coin (and the Proof 1855 that followed), he went to the podium as it was being sold as raised his arm like the proverbial Statue of Liberty. His strategy proved to be lucrative as he was able to buy the coin in 1956 for just $525; a pretty decent return on investment over a forty-year hold.
My favorite early half eagle in the sale was, without a doubt, the amazing Proof 1833 which was one of just two known and the only one available to collectors. I graded it PR66+ and described it as follows in the catalog: “INCREDIBLE!!!!” It sold for $467,500. In January 2005, the same coin, graded PR67 by PCGS, sold for $977,500. I still regard this as one of the single greatest early gold coins I have ever seen. Just as an FYI, Pittman bought the coin from the Farouk sale in 1954 and paid all of $635.
There were two Proof Classic Head half eagles that weren’t far behind the 1833 on the DW cool-o-meter scale. The first was an 1835 (one of three known and one of two owned by Pittman) and an 1836 (one of three known). The 1835 sold for $308,000 while the 1836 brought $198,000. In January 2005, the 1835, graded PR67 by PCGS, sold for $690,000 while the 1836, as far as I know, has not traded at auction since the Pittman sale.
There were some amazing Liberty Head half eagles in the collection and, interestingly, nearly all of them came from the same source(s): the Farouk sale of 1954 with earlier ownership by Col. Green.
Some of the coins that I remember most include an 1840-C that is now graded MS64 (it has sold at least three or four times since the Pittman auction and is easily the finest known), a superb MS63 1840-O (I have handled it twice since Pittman and it is among the nicest New Orleans half eagles of any date), a killer MS62 1842 Large Letters and an MS64 1844-D (now in the Duke’s Creek collection and easily the finest known).
One really controversial coin in the half eagle section was Lot 981, an 1847 that was essentially perfect but which had a HUGE (and I mean huge!) copper stain on the reverse. Some people absolutely loved the coin while others couldn’t stand it. In the end the “lovers” won out as it brought an amazing $110,000.
Perhaps the number one “sleeper” coin in the half eagle section was Lot 984, an 1847-O half eagle that was graded “Extremely Fine to About Uncirculated” in the catalog. I thought the coin was a nice AU55 and felt it was the second finest I had ever seen, after the Eliasberg/Milas coin. I wound up bidding $18,000 and lost out. It brought $24,200 and was later graded MS61 by NGC where it remains the only example graded Mint State by either service.
One last coin, then we’ll end this overlong remembrance. Lot 1022 was an 1859-D half eagle that I graded MS64 to MS65. I recall speaking with the late Jack Hancock before the sale and discussing this coin. He didn’t say much about it (I knew he loved it as much as I did) and I knew he had a customer who would pretty much pay whatever it took. Jack wound-up paying $60,500 for the coin which is still in the Duke’s Creek collection and which was graded MS64 by PCGS after the auction.
The first session of the Pittman sale brought $11,820,512. I can recall thinking the coins brought “all the money” at the time but looking back at the catalog today I’m struck at how reasonable many of these irreplaceable coins were. What is most stunning, though, is to see the prices that Pittman paid in the 1940’s, 1950’s and 1960’s. If there was ever proof that really good coins held for a long time are really good investment, it was the Pittman sale!