DWN IS THE SOURCE FOR CHOICE, RARE PRE-1933 US GOLD COINAGE
ON HOLD - $2.50 - 1864 PCGS AU58 CAC
ON HOLD - $2.50 - 1864 PCGS AU58 CAC
Date……….1864
Grade…….PCGS AU58 CAC
PCGS Price Guide.…….……150,000
CDN Greysheet/CPG.…..…144,000
Population (PCGS).………….4/1
Population (NGC).….….….…2/3
Population (CAC).…..…….….3/0
Serial Number……7800.58/81307068
PCGS Lookup Number.….7800
THIRD FINEST KNOWN 1864 QUARTER EAGLE
I could go on and on with superlatives about this issue and this particular coin but in respect for your time, I will not be spending the next half hour pouring my heart out about the 1864 quarter eagle. Suffice to say, it is the rarest Philadelphia quarter eagle of this type made for circulation and it is the second rarest circulation strike issue of the entire series, trailing only the 1854-S. There were just 2,824 struck with an estimated 25 or so known today.
Of the three PCGS AU58 coins that have been graded, this piece is by a huge margin the best. It has lovely original color with rich reddish coloration on the obverse and the reverse. Wear is minimal and there is a good amount of luster seen. A few mint-made planchet lines run upwards from the corner of the eye towards the tip of the coronet, and on the reverse there is an area of deep color that runs from the rim at 5:00 through the CA in AMERICA terminating right under the arrows. The overall eye appeal is excellent for the grade and what we have here is the rare situation where good looks and true rarity meet in one small package.
The finest known 1864 quarter eagles are as follows:
NGC MS67: Florida Collection, ex Byron Reed
PCGS MS61: Kansas Collection, ex DWN
PCGS/CAC AU58: This example, ex South Texas Collection via DWN; Legend 12/2020: 21 ($111,625); Heritage 2017 ANA: 4092 ($79,312; as PCGS 58)
PCGS/CAC AU55: Stack’s Bowers 3/2011: 6283 ($46,000)
PCGS/CAC AU50: Private Collection via Legend RC, ex Heritage 9/2026:3616 ($100,650).
With the recent sale of a PCGS/CAC for $115,000, I feel that this significantly finer coin is a much better value.
CAC has approved this single coin in AU58 with none finer.





Date……….1842
Grade…….PCGS AU58
PCGS Price Guide.…….……25000
Population (PCGS).……….….…3/3
Population (NGC).……...…….…4/1
Serial Number……7723.58/46198714
PCGS Lookup Number.…….7723